Love Story Cakes
Price per serving
Starts at $3 per person.
About Love Story Cakes
Katie McVay
Hello I’m Katie! Owner and operator of Love Story Cakes! I have a Bachelors Degree in Baking and Pastry Arts from Johnson and Wales University and I’ve been in the business for over 16 years. I love to make delicious desserts and edible works of art. I’m very passionate and strive to have everything I make be the best it can be for your wedding day!
Customizable is a big thing that sets us apart! We offer several different cake, filling, and icing selections that can be mixed and matched to make your perfect combination! We also offer cake stand rentals and cake and dessert staging. We know wedding planning can be extremely stressful so we strive to make the ordering process easy and fun! We would be so honored to be a part of your special day!
Services
Dessert types
- Cakes
- Cookies and macarons
- Cupcakes
- Mini desserts
- Novelties and other
Decor options
- Cake toppers
- Custom text
- Live flowers
- Sugar flowers
Available customizations
- Cake filling
- Cake flavors
- Cake frosting
Services offered
- Consultations
- Delivery
- Setup
- Tastings
Dietary accommodations
- Vegetarian
Reviews
Write a review5.0 out of 5
17 reviews
- NW
Natalie & W.
Amazing Wedding Desserts
We absolutely loved working with Katie from Love Story Cakes! She did an amazing job creating our autumn cake and cake shots for our wedding. The guests raved about the cake shots the whole night! We also really appreciated getting to try different flavor combinations before committing to the final options. Would definitely recommend her for wedding desserts!
- CL
Claire L.
Best Cakes Ever
I first tasted Katie's work at a friend's wedding in 2025 and was blown away by the quality of her cake. As someone who takes desserts seriously, I knew right away we had to hire Love Story Cakes for our big day. Katie created our wedding cake and gluten-free cupcakes, and she was a joy to work with from start to finish. She communicated clearly throughout the planning process and delivered exactly what we envisioned. The best part? Every single dessert was gone by the end of the night – not a crumb left behind. That's the ultimate compliment, and we couldn't be happier with our choice.
- LR
Lauren R.
Delicious and Beautiful Wedding Cake
Katie from Love Story Cakes was fantastic to work with! She quickly responded to all emails and was flexible throughout the process. She set up a tasting for us to make sure we loved our wedding cake flavor. The cake not only looked beautiful but was delcious as well! She even had the option to add gluten free cupcakes for gluten free guests. We cannot recommend Love Story Cakeds enough!
- S
Sophie
Amazing cake & experience!
We had an incredible experience working with Love Story Cakes for our wedding day. From start to finish, the communication was just right: we got the updates we needed without feeling overwhelmed. Katie took our ideas and inspiration photos and created something truly special that went beyond what we imagined. The cake was stunning to look at and tasted incredible, with every flavor perfectly balanced. Our guests couldn't stop talking about how beautiful and delicious it was. Love Story Cakes deserves five stars, and we'd recommend them to any couple without hesitation.
- RC
Rachel C.
Highly recommend!
It was so wonderful to work with Katie from start to finish. She's quick to communicate, has an extensive list of choices, and of course is an excellent baker. We ordered a small two tier cake, several flavors of cupcakes, and gluten free cupcakes. All were delicious, and we received so many compliments. I highly recommend working with Katie and Love Story Cakes.
Explore other vendors serving Waconia, MN
- Divine Swine Catering
- Kmb Floral
- Corey Christian Photography
- Piccadilly Pours - Modern Mobile Bartending
- Tayler Dumas Photography
- Debra Aslanidis Photography
- Hello Wildflower
- engraveVine
- Satcher Productions
- DropsofGrace Photography
- VTN Photo
- Kikonda Films
Complete your dream team
- Waconia Venues
- Waconia Photographers
- Waconia Beauty Professionals
- Waconia Bands & DJs
- Waconia Florists
- Waconia Caterers
- Waconia Planners
- Waconia Videographers
- Waconia Bar Services & Beverages
- Waconia Officiants
- Waconia Event Extras
Other cakes & desserts in Waconia
- Sweet Kneads Farmington Bakery
- Sweet Buckets
- Sweet Assurance
- Bebe Zito Ice Cream
- Lily Bean Bakery
- Bridgeman's Ice Cream Parlor
- Keys Cafe & Bakery
- Waddup Dough!
- Sweetie Pucks
- My Liege Waffles
- Sara's Tipsy Pies
- Milly Vanilly