Two Hearts Catering

Ratings include Zola and Google reviews

About Two Hearts Catering

Two Hearts Catering

Owner

At Two Hearts we're more than just a catering company- we're a family driven business passionate about bringing people together over delicious food. As Italian Americans food is in our DNA. We believe that sharing a meal is about connection, love and community. Our team led by CEO Lisa is dedicated to crafting customized menus that exceeds expectations. whether it's a corporate event, wedding, or special celebration, we're committed to delivering exceptional service, fresh ingredients, and a dash of heart.

At Two Hearts, we're passionate about serving more than just food we serve experiences. As an Italian American catering company, we blend tradition with creativity to bring your events to life. What sets us apart: Customized menus, tailored to your taste Fresh locally sourced ingredients Personalized service from our team Unique offerings like limo and party bus referrals with our associate partners Meal prep services for hassle free experience for gift openings and getting ready moments. Grilling fresh on site bringing the kitchen trattoria to you Let's bring Two Hearts to your table


Services

Cuisines

  • American
  • BBQ
  • Farm-to-table
  • French
  • Greek
  • Italian
  • Mexican
  • Seafood
  • Southern
  • Southwestern
  • Spanish

Dietary accommodations

  • Dairy-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Halal
  • Kosher
  • Nut-free
  • Organic
  • Vegan
  • Vegetarian

Meal types

  • Breakfast/brunch
  • Buffet
  • Dessert service
  • Family-style meal
  • Food stations
  • Passed appetizers
  • Seated meal
  • Stationary appetizers

Beverage services

  • Bartending
  • Mixers/non-alcoholic options

Drink types

  • Beer
  • Coffee service
  • Liquor
  • Mobile bar
  • Non-alcoholic
  • Signature cocktails
  • Wine

Reviews

Write a review
Rating: 4.8

4.8 out of 5

20 reviews

  • AN

    Amber Nieman

    Rating: 5
    Google
    Aug 17, 2026

    I hired Two Hearts Catering for my sons graduation party this August. They were initially booked already for that day, but offered to still work with me and do party trays. We communicated back and forth and they gave me some ideas. We decided to do sandwich trays, potato salad, pasta salad and all the fixings and condiments for the sandwiches along with cookie platters. Everything was great and more than expected. They delivered to my event location the day of the party. We had more than enough food and everyone was very pleased and impressed. I will hire them again in the future. Great to work with and they made the whole process very easy!

    Two Hearts CateringAug 17, 2026

    Thank you so much for your kindness words and support it means a lot to help others in the community.

  • AS

    Anna Seydel

    Rating: 5
    Google
    Aug 14, 2026

    Peter was a pleasure to work with—extremely available and professional. The food was exquisite and the service was exactly what I wanted for our outdoor graduation party hosting 70 people.

    Two Hearts CateringAug 14, 2026

    Thank you for your incredible support and it was a pleasure serving your surgeon group. We look forward to catering your next holiday party. Respectfully Peter Two Hearts Hospitality Group

  • LW

    Liz Wall

    Rating: 5
    Google
    Aug 8, 2026

    Absolutely wonderful to work with!!!

    Two Hearts CateringAug 8, 2026

    Thank you so much. We appreciate your comment.

  • RK

    Rachel Kubacki

    Rating: 5
    Google
    Jul 3, 2026

    We used Two Hearts Catering for our wedding a couple weeks ago and we’re still talking about the food! Everything about this experience was top notch and completely exceeded expectations. Right off the bat, they were able to accommodate for our short notice decision to have a small wedding. After a super informative discussion, we felt confident with our choice of the herbed chicken with Marsala sauce, mushroom risotto, broccolini, and Caesar salad. And let me tell you, they did not disappoint. Everything was amazing and the chicken and risotto were favorites amongst the crowd! Prior to dinner we had a variety of appetizers for our guests and the spread was incredible. We had spinach artichoke dip and a charcuterie, cheese, and veggie board. It was so nicely displayed and plenty for our guests to enjoy. Everyone was very well fed at our wedding! Not only was the food exceptional, but so was their customer service. It was a real pleasure getting to work with Peter prior to our day. He is genuinely one of the kindest, most considerate people I’ve ever worked with. It was clear right away that he has years of experience in this industry and that he cares about the people he does business with. We were trying to put together a wedding last minute and his expertise helped us think of things we wouldn’t have considered. We also greatly appreciated the local suggestions for other things like flowers, DJ, and dessert. He mentioned a couple times that he treats his customers like family and would do what they could to make the day easier for us and we really did feel that way during this entire experience. I would recommend Two Hearts Catering in a heartbeat and we’re looking forward to the next time we need catering!

    Two Hearts CateringJul 3, 2026

    Thank you so much for the review we loved serving you both and your families. We wish you both the very best. The Herbed chicken and risotto is a true client favorite. We are glad we were able to step in and make your day beautiful. We look forward to celebrating with you at your anniversary party

  • TA

    Tina Adamski

    Rating: 5
    Google
    Jun 28, 2026

    We couldn't have been happier with the catering at our daughter's wedding! The food was absolutely amazing—everything tasted fresh, flavorful, and was beautifully prepared. The staff was super friendly, professional, and easy to communicate with throughout the planning process, which made everything so much less stressful. Family-style service was a little slow getting to all the tables, but the quality and freshness of the food made it well worth the wait. We would definitely recommend them for any special event!

    Two Hearts CateringJun 28, 2026

    Thank you so much for your feedback. We were honored you chose us for your daughter’s wedding caterer. It was a pleasure to serve you. We wish you all the very best.


Yes, our event minimum is $1500 for all weddings except drop off party platters.
Yes, we offer tastings for you and a guest for a small fee. If you sign a contract with us beforehand, we can waive this fee.
We are full service. We will take you on a walk-through of available rentals and work with you to find options within your budget or make suggestions for use of our vendor partners.
Yes, we charge a standard fee for delivery outside our home base area. Additional fees may apply to deliveries greater than 150 miles.
We recommend meeting 2 more times after your tasting. One meeting will focus on finalizing menus and headcount. One to go over final venue and wedding logistics.
For summer and fall weddings, we recommend at least 10 months in advance.
We serve all of Wisconsin
We can provide individual Kosher or Halal meals and customize fully vegetarian or vegan menus as well as Celiac and Gluten free or pescatarian.
For a fee per person, we can cut and serve your wedding cake to your guests.