Old Souls Catering

Ratings include Zola and Google reviews

Catering services pricing

Food starts at $14 per person and bar services at $16 per person.

Minimum spend

$5,000 total


About Old Souls Catering

Old Souls Catering

Chef/Owner

Growing up in Wyoming County, the heart of New York’s dairy & farming industry, Josh has a real appreciation for fresh food products. His family’s restaurants and their farms sparked a passion for carefully choosing sources of food. Josh’s dedication to sourcing and using the best fresh and local products is evident in his cooking. Josh went to culinary school at Johnson & Wales University in North Miami. He took the skills he learned from working in his family and other local restaurants and continued to develop them at J&W. After culinary school, Josh came back to Western New York and opened a catering business.

We make you and your guests feel like family, with elevated, locally sourced food. Our focus on using local ingredients, providing all the services you need from food, beverages & bar, desserts & coffee to linens and more!


Services

Services

  • Bartenders
  • Cleanup and breakdown
  • Consultations and tastings - complimentary
  • Consultations and tastings - for a fee
  • Delivery and setup
  • Event planner
  • Rental coordination - directly invoice couple
  • Serving staff

Cuisines

  • American
  • BBQ
  • Cajun
  • Eastern European
  • Farm-to-table
  • French
  • Fusion
  • Greek
  • Italian
  • Mexican
  • Seafood
  • Southern
  • Southwestern
  • Spanish

Dietary accommodations

  • Dairy-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Nut-free
  • Organic
  • Vegan
  • Vegetarian

Meal types

  • Breakfast/brunch
  • Buffet
  • Dessert service
  • Family-style meal
  • Food stations
  • Passed appetizers
  • Seated meal
  • Stationary appetizers
  • Wedding cake service

Beverage services

  • Bartending
  • Beverage servingware rentals
  • Mixers/non-alcoholic options
  • Provides liquor license

Drink types

  • Beer
  • Coffee service
  • Liquor
  • Mobile bar
  • Non-alcoholic
  • Signature cocktails
  • Wine

Extra costs

  • Bartender services
  • Consultation / Tasting
  • Corkage Fee
  • Extra hour of service
  • Gratuity
  • Liquor License
  • Rentals - beverage ware
  • Rentals - dining ware
  • Rentals - furniture
  • Rentals - linens
  • Service Fee
  • Wedding Cake & Dessert Service

Reviews

Write a review
Rating: 4.6

4.6 out of 5

13 reviews

  • AD

    Amy D'Ambrose

    Rating: 5
    Google
    Jul 27, 2026

    I was hesitant to hire a caterer for my daughter’s wedding reception from an area I was not from but I couldn’t be happier with my choice. From our first meeting with Josh, I could tell he was experienced and well organized. Throughout the process he got back to me promptly with my questions and last minute changes. He and his team took charge at the venue and displayed the food beautifully. Most importantly, everything was delicious. This was for a party for 150 people who all raved about how good it was. The staff packaged up all the leftovers for the bride and groom to enjoy. It was so nice to be able to enjoy the evening without having to worry about the clean up. The kitchen area was spotless. Thanks Josh!!!!

  • RW

    Rachel Wood

    Rating: 5
    Google
    Jul 9, 2026

    Old souls catered my daughter’s graduation party. We had beef on weck, salt potatoes, baked beans, and coleslaw. Everything was delicious. So much so that everyone came back for more and I ran out of beef. I definitely recommend Old Souls Catering. I have also visited the bakery which is delicious!

  • CM

    Chris Monteleone

    Rating: 2
    Google
    Sep 30, 2025

    Went to a wedding - fruits and hors d’oeurve table was great The buffet dinner however was horrific! Raw ribs, servings were minimally portioned and cold The workers were cranky and disorganized - clearing water glasses before dinner was even eaten, spilling drinks and clearing the half bottles of wine off the tables during the dinner. Very disappointed !!! Wouldn’t recommend them for any occassion

  • NA

    Nichole Andino

    Rating: 5
    Google
    Sep 15, 2025

    My husband and I chose Old Souls to cater our wedding. Not only did they meet all of our catering needs, but they also handled all of our bar service needs as well. I have so many great things to say about Old Souls!! First and foremost we did have a handful of allergies and old souls gave everyone an experience they could enjoy and we had absolutely no allergy problems at all!! My husband and I were over the moon about how delicious their food was. I would recommend Old Souls to absolutely everyone! Every single item on our menu tasted nothing short of incredible! They provided exceptional service for not only us as the newlyweds, but for ALL of our guests as well. My husband and I had gone back and forth on what we wanted on our menu many times. We had reached out to change things many times as well and each time Josh handled it with so much patience, grace, and efficiency. Closer to our wedding my husband and I had also decided to have an open bar for just our wedding party and parents. We had already opted for a cash bar for the event. When we reached out about the change to have open bar for the wedding party, Josh again not only met our needs but did it efficiently and made the entire process COMPLETELY stress free!! The staff from Old Souls were so amazing. They were very professional and set everything up with ease. We had one bar outside for cocktail hour and one inside for our reception and the transition between bars was handled so well that I hadn’t even noticed! The bar tenders made incredible drinks and helped us manage our bar top guest book to make sure every signature or note written was tasteful! When the rest of the staff cleaned up the buffet, they packed away whatever was left for my husband and I to take home. We ate our leftovers up so fast because we just couldn’t get enough of their amazing food!! We are so thankful that we had our day catered by Old Souls. They provided us with such an incredible, delicious, and stress free experience for our wedding day. Thank you again to Josh for giving us the best dinner on our wedding day and for having such wonderful food/drinks and even better staff!! Our day wouldn’t have been the same without Old Souls!

  • JL

    Jennifer Lead

    Rating: 5
    Google
    Sep 7, 2025

    I cannot rave enough about this caterer. Exceptional. My daughter and son in law used them for their wedding weekend at Brooksholm. Everything/everyone was amazing. Food, presentation, staff. Thank you so much Old Souls Catering.


Preferred vendors of Old Souls Catering

Venue
Graceful Gatherings at LedgeRock
Venue
Breezeway Barns & Garden
Venue
East Hill Creamery
Perry, NY
Florist
Bush Hill Florist And Gift Shoppe

For summer and fall weddings, we recommend at least 16 months in advance.
We can provide individual fully vegetarian or vegan menus, we can accomodate dairy free, soy free, gluten free guests. Please ask for any other dietary needs!
For a small per person fee, we can cut and serve your wedding cake to your guests.
Delivery fees within a 25 mile radius of Perry, NY are included with the service fee. Additional fees may apply to deliveries to other areas.
We are full service. We will take you on a walk-through of available rentals and work with you to find options within your budget.