The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Smithtown, NY

The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Smithtown, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


48 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Smithtown, NY

Quick responder
Veg On Board 
Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)
  • Starts at $250
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

Veg on Board is a boutique, plant-based cake studio serving Long Island and NYC. I’m Irene, the cake designer behind Veg on Board, and I create custom cakes, desserts and grazing tables for weddings and events. Each cake is designed to reflect each couple’s style and vision, and made to taste as good as it looks. Every cake is baked from scratch using premium ingredients and thoughtfully developed recipes. Alongside classic flavors, I also offer Latin tropical options, bringing something a little different that’s close to my roots.

Awarded Best of Zola
“Veg On Board was an absolute delight to work with for our wedding cakes. Their communication was quick, reliable, and clarifying throughout the entire process. They truly brought my vision to life, recreating a reference photo I shared but making it even better. The taste was incredible - I highly recommend doing a tasting box to play around with flavors! We also got a charcuterie board from them for our getting ready time, which was the perfect addition. I cannot recommend Veg On Board enough for your wedding or any special occasion - they will exceed your expectations!”
Samantha E., 10 months ago
GemHidden gem
MWDyes Sweets 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $525
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

I have been baking for 10+ years, and been in business for 5 years. What started off as a hobby turned into my greatest passion. I love bringing others vision to life through cake, I love the looks on my customer faces when thier dream cake comes into the room, this is my passion and I live what I do. I am here to make sure your special day goes as planned, and I am just grateful to be apart of making your day special.

Awarded Best of Zola
“I recently placed an order with MWDyes, and it was by far the best decision I ever made. Not only was the cake beautiful, it was delicious. The vanilla buttercream is my favorite! My guest wanted seconds and I ate left overs at 12 am the next day because it was that good ! Place your orders today, you won’t regret it !”
Faith G., 3 years ago
Quick responder
Peach & Pine 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
  • Starts at $160
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

Thanks for stopping by! Here at Peach & Pine we create custom cakes & small batch pastries for weddings and all other special occasions. We specialize in ornate lambeth (vintage) cake designs with layers of detailed Italian meringue buttercream piping, painted buttercream cakes, & other designs that follow our clean aesthetic. We focus heavily on the quality of our ingredients. We source local wherever possible and make absolutely everything in-house.

“Ashely is a joy to work with, and her creativity really shines! She was able to include some clay figures I purchased of our two dogs. Her vintage style cakes are so beautiful and intricate. I don’t usually even like eating cake, but I loved the cake we chose for our wedding. We bought extra for our guests and there was NONE left at the end of the night.”
Mel, 9 months ago
GemHidden gem
The Little Lion Bakeshop 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
  • Starts at $48
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

A local baker specializing in custom sugar cookies and shortbread in a variety of flavors! Need a photo on a cookie? I'm your guy! Almost any photo can be printed and the cookies can be almost any flavor (excluding chocolate)!

“I had a wonderful experience working with The Little Lion Bakeshop. Their communication was always effective and timely, making the ordering process smooth and easy. The quality of their work is exceptional - the customized cookies they provided were absolutely delicious and beautifully presented. They truly went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect, tailoring the cookies to the occasion. I would highly recommend The Little Lion Bakeshop!”
David, a year ago
TrendlineTrending
Don Cannoli, LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (106 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

Premium cannoli, hand-piped by The Don himself! We make cannoli you can't refuse, featuring handmade shells imported from Sicily and fresh cannoli cream prepared for the day of your event. Our lavish cannoli concierge service is perfect for weddings, backyard birthdays, holiday parties, corporate events, and more!

“They made our wedding day unforgettable. They didn't just deliver desserts, they were part of the celebration, moving around the room, dancing with guests, and even jumping into our photobooth! The quality of their work was outstanding, and they stayed engaged throughout the night! We were blown away by how much they cared about making our evening special.”
Kristin I., a month ago
Quick responder
Mackenzie Rose Bakes 
Rating: 5.0 (10 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $6
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

Hi, I’m Mackenzie, the cake artist behind Mackenzie Rose Bakes! After a few years in corporate America, I made the leap to pursue what I’d always loved most: creating beautiful cakes that make celebrations unforgettable. I trained in pastry at the Institute of Culinary Education in New York City, where I’m based. I love bold colors, intricate designs, and delicious flavors. Every cake is made from scratch with premium ingredients and designed around your vision, whether that’s a romantic tiered centerpiece with fresh florals or a classic cake with delicate vintage-style piping. Wedding cakes are personal, and I treat each one as a one-of-a-kind piece made just for you!

“Mackenzie Rose Bakes made our wedding dessert experience incredible from start to finish. She was responsive to every question we had and worked with us to create exactly what we envisioned for our big day. The cake itself was stunning – it looked beautiful on display and tasted even better than we expected. Mackenzie was flexible when we needed adjustments and brought a true professional approach to the whole process. Our guests could not stop raving about how delicious everything was. We would absolutely recommend her to any couple looking for a baker who cares about getting every detail right.”
Ella, 6 days ago
Quick responder
Rosebloom Cakes 
Rating: 5.0 (9 reviews)
  • Starts at $500
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

I'm a former costume designer and fashion historian with a PhD in English literature, now using my love of art, craft, and design to create one-of-a-kind custom wedding cakes! I make delicious, colorful cakes in traditional and modern flavor combinations, topped with handcrafted sugar flowers. I use only the highest-quality ingredients and always emphasize both design and taste. I would love to work with you to make your cake one of the most memorable and beautiful parts of your wedding!

Awarded Best of Zola
“I absolutely loved my cake from Rosebloom Cakes for my wedding! Not only was is stunning to look at with the hand made sugar flowers but it was also extremely delicious! Multiple guests told us that they loved the flavors of the cake (vanilla sponge with raspberry curd and lemon ganache). I also loved having the sugar flowers and the top layer to take home with me after the wedding. The flowers are just too pretty to eat and are displayed on a shelf, and we were told they practically last forever which is also pretty cool.”
Jinnie K., a month ago
GemHidden gem
Cakes by Magda 
Rating: 5.0 (6 reviews)
  • Starts at $500
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

Hi! Privately I am a mom of a 4 year old girl and a wife, on the business side aside from being a bookkeeper for a construction company I also love Coordinating business for mom. I love planning for not only weddings but all other events for my mom too. I get excited about every single lead and I invest all of my time to answer and help out our customer. Looking forward to working with you! <3

Awarded Best of Zola
“Cakes by Magda really set themselves apart from the other vendors. So many options and all so good! We went with the coconut and loved it! Weronika was responsive, professional, and made my dream cake come through. Highly recommend!”
Gabriela, 4 years ago
Quick responder
Sweet Kee's Candies & Gifts 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $150
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

Sweet Kee's is a one-of-a-kind Hudson Valley, New York wedding favors & gifts business, servicing couples throughout New York State. We offer handcrafted, artisanal treats, including a variety of classic & specialty hard candies & lollipops that are perfect as candy or dessert table options, as gifts and favors. We also offer premium beverage infusion kits that allow your guests to create their own craft drink experience. Just add wine, liquor, or non-alcoholic beverages. Our other specialty food novelties include hot cocoa jars, small-batch fruit jams, and edible peppermint shot glasses. Shipping is available throughout New York State.

Awarded Best of Zola
“I buy Sweet Kee's lollipops REGULARLY. The flavors and artistry and attentiveness to each customized purchase is incomparable to any other consumable brands out there. I am a repeat customer and do not believe that will ever change! (Because these lollipops have become a fact of life for me.)”
Lucky, 2 years ago
GemHidden gem
Cake Hero 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

Based in Brooklyn, self taught sugar artist Melissa Torres knows that there’s nothing like a gorgeous and delicious treat to take your party to the next level! With a commitment to using organic, fair trade ingredients, Cake Hero confections are beautiful and delicious delights that you can feel good about. Your purchase of a Cake Hero cake means that together, we are a force for good in our business and purchasing practices. We extend this way of thinking to our packaging, and use recycled boxes and paper whenever possible. Melissa’s unique take on cake has caught the eye of Vogue, New York Magazine, and many stylish events in NYC & beyond.

“We loved working with Melissa to achieve the look and taste we wanted for our beautiful wedding cakes! We wanted multiple, coordinated cakes, all of different flavors and colors, and Melissa delivered a quartet that exceeded even what we were hoping for! Our cakes were featured in Vogue magazine under the heading "The Confectionary Equivalent to Couture" which was really fun to see. Melissa uses all organic and fair trade ingredients, which is an added bonus. Best of all, she's a stellar human who makes you feel happy and cared for.”
Hillary and D., 6 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Petrova Chocolates 
Rating: 5.0 (4 reviews)
  • Starts at $400
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

Petrova Chocolates was established in 2020 and since then we have been focusing on creating eye-catching, artisanal chocolate bonbons, truffles, chocolate bars and caramels with unique flavor combinations. Our chocolates are the perfect sweet touch to every event whether as a guest gift, a chocolate dessert table set-up or as a delicious name tag at every guest's seat. We are excited to hear from you and be given the opportunity to sweeten your special day!

Awarded Best of Zola
“I tried Petrova Chocolates for the first time at a Winter market last year in Boston. I bought the Milk chocolate with crispy crepe and cinnamon and the signature Bonbon collection and can tell that the chocolates were amazing. I have been ordering since then and would definitely recommend the Strawberry and Cream bar. All of the chocolates in her selection are unique and I can tell that it is the best homemade chocolate I've ever had. Petrova Chocolates is the place to go for any event from a birthday party to a wedding. The owner, Betty is also very responsive and always makes sure that her clients are satisfied with their orders.”
Before You Say I Do, 3 years ago
GemHidden gem
Paanmasti LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $300
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

Niki Vaswani created Paanmasti from a heartfelt wish to bring a beautiful piece of her heritage into life’s most meaningful celebrations. Growing up, paan was more than a treat, it was a moment of joy shared at weddings, family gatherings, and milestones. When Niki moved to New York, she dreamed of reimagining that tradition with elegance and modern flair. Paanmasti was born to offer FDA Approved, tobacco-free, handcrafted, upscale paan that feels special—something memorable for brides, grooms, and guests. For Niki, every paan is crafted with love, nostalgia, and the hope of adding a sweet, unique touch to your wedding day.

“Paanmasti LLC is an excellent choice for wedding desserts. Their communication throughout the process was highly professional and they were extremely well-informed about their products and services. The quality of their reimagined upscale, FDA-approved Paan was truly impressive. I was thrilled with the final results and would highly recommend them to any couple planning their wedding. Their attention to detail and commitment to delivering a top-notch experience is unparalleled.”
Mike V., 10 months ago
GemHidden gem
Azerbaijani Delight 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
  • Starts at $250
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

Growing up, every spring was more than just a season — it was a celebration. I remember standing beside my mom in the kitchen, where the air was filled with the sweet aroma of honey and nuts. Aunties, grandmas, and neighbors would gather, laughter and stories mixing as they rolled, layered, and baked baklava together. Baklava wasn’t just a dessert; it was a symbol of community, love, and tradition. Now, starting my own journey far from home, I bring that same spirit with me and hope to share it with my new community. Let Azerbaijani Delight baklavas be part of your story, sharing love, togetherness with your guests on your special day.

Awarded Best of Zola
“I ordered baklava for our engagement celebration, and it was absolutely perfect. The presentation was beautiful, the baklava was incredibly fresh, and the taste was outstanding. Everyone at the party kept asking where we got it from. The customer service was also excellent and very responsive. I will definitely order from them again for future events!”
Farida, a year ago
GemHidden gem
The Scoop Ices 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
  • Starts at $400
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

The Scoop Ices is a premium Italian ice company specializing in handcrafted, refreshing treats for weddings and special events. We focus on high-quality ingredients, smooth texture, and vibrant flavors, all served with a clean, modern presentation that elevates any celebration. Our goal is to create a memorable, feel-good experience your guests will enjoy from the first scoop to the last.

“The Scoop Ices is absolutely amazing! The Italian ices are incredibly refreshing, full of flavor, and clearly made with quality ingredients. Every flavor is smooth, vibrant, and not overly sweet. Their setup is clean, professional, and perfect for any event. Highly recommend!”
Rita, 9 months ago
CakeSpell Delightful Baking 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $375
  • Serves Smithtown, NY

Servicing all of Connecticut, CakeSpell Delightful Baking is a concierge bakery located in Waterbury, CT. CakeSpell is your baker and cake decorator. Whether you or your guest prefer an array of dietary options, such as gluten-free or vegan options, or would like to incorporate a cultural recipe such as plum pudding as a tribute to your grandmother; we can accommodate you without sacrificing the visual appeal of your wedding day. We work closely with each client, providing our undivided attention to bring your dreams to reality.

“My experience with the cakes Bell was superb and very professional. I was very happy with our cake and would order from them again.”
Michael, 6 years ago
Quick responder
NYCakes Boutique 
Rating: 4.9 (54 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $400
  • Serves Smithtown, NY for additional fees

At NYCakes Boutique, a family business, we believe that your wedding cake should be as unforgettable as your love story. From our family to yours, we guide you through every step and aspect of planning your special day piece. With over 8 years specialized in events like yours, we know that planning and executing a wedding event is no easy task. Therefore, we assist you from beginning to end, to make sure that your cake experience is as seamless and enjoyable as it can get.

“We knew NYCakes Boutique was the right choice after learning about the chef's background and passion for her craft. From our first conversation, the team was quick to respond to our texts and worked with us to confirm all the flavors we wanted. They really listened to our feedback and adjusted their vision to match what we had in mind. On our wedding day, the cake was an absolute showstopper and our guests couldn't stop talking about it. Several people mentioned it was actually cake they enjoyed, unlike the typical wedding cake. The whole thing tasted as good as it looked. We're so grateful to NYCakes Boutique for creating something truly special for our celebration.”
Lauren L., 4 months ago
Quick responder
Little Treats and Cakes by Janna, LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (9 reviews)
  • Starts at $360
  • Serves Smithtown, NY for additional fees

Little Treats and Cakes by Janna specializes in wedding cakes and specialty cakes for all occasions. Our commitment is to create an original piece of edible art, that it’s not only beautiful but also very delicious. We not only offer cakes but also a variety of treats for your event like custom cupcakes, sugar cookies, and a full dessert menu which is created to match the theme and design of your event for an unforgettable sweets table. We also offer guest edible favors. At Little Treats and Cakes by Janna we also offer gluten free, dairy free and vegan options if you have dietary restrictions.

Awarded Best of Zola
“Working with Janna at Little Treats and Cakes was a game-changer for our wedding day. She responded quickly to every question and made the whole process feel collaborative and stress-free, which meant we could focus on other details instead of worrying about desserts. Janna took our vision and turned it into gorgeous cakes and mini bites that tasted as good as they looked and fit our theme perfectly. Her desserts were delicious and she clearly put thought into every detail. She also made us a gorgeous anniversary cake! If you want beautiful, flavorful desserts without the headache of planning them yourself, Janna is your person. We couldn't have asked for better service or a sweeter experience working with her.”
Arielle I., 3 months ago
Hanami Cake Design 
Rating: 4.8 (6 reviews)
  • Serves Smithtown, NY for additional fees

Hanami Cake Design was born out of the desire to ensure that everyone can eat dessert whenever they want to! We offer luxury cakes and personalized dessert tables, including cupcakes, whoopie pies, tarts, macarons, pies, doughnuts, and more! We offer an entirely custom experience for our couples, from different sweets, to flavors and designs. We can also offer nearly everything in a variety of allergen-friendly options, including gluten-free, vegan, dairy-free, nut-free, organic, and refined sugar free! We are passionate about creating a unique experience for our couples, a sustainable business for our planet, and dessert for all!

“Martha was amazing!!!! We were blown away with Martha's capability in design, flavor and originality. She was very exciting and collaborative in developing the flavors we envisioned for our wedding day. As an Asian American, there is a void in Asian flavors in cakes/designs in the area of Maine/New Hampshire that we are in. She not only is excited about Asian flavor profiles but has training and experiences with this. She not only created a custom cake flavor (Honey Ginger Cake) but custom dessert bar as well (Adzuki hamentaschen, Matcha cupcake with strawberry compote and adzuki vegan buttercream, and Black Sesame-Dark Chocolate Mochi). The desserts and cake were absolutely delicious and everyone raved about the variety and expertise of the desserts. We definitely heard people say that our cake was the best cake they have ever had at a wedding. Not only did she make original recipes for our wedding, but also complied with the number of dietary restrictions that were needed for our wedding day (dairy free). Her cake design and attention to detail was amazing. She made a ton of little easter eggs of our favorite characters and symbols that were important to us. We have been so pleased and would use her again for any specialty desserts we may need for an event or just for ourselves. We cannot wait for our anniversary cake. She is so worth it. There were times she was busy that she warned us about that would make it hard to communicate with her. We understood and trusted her plan and process and couldn't have been happier with everything. Martha brings a ton of great energy to the process of wedding dessert planning. We strongly recommend her and for any Asians looking for an Asian styled/flavored cake, I would recommend Hanami Cake and as the greatest compliment from an Asian her desserts were 'Not Too Sweet." Absolutely Amazing!”
Derek L., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Sweet Buckets 
Rating: 5.0 (5 reviews)
  • Starts at $300
  • Serves Smithtown, NY for additional fees

We began as a concession company providing cotton candy at sporting events. In the fall of 2021, we extended our brand by starting our own manufacturing plant. Sweet Buckets was born as an option for customers and businesses to purchase Cotton Candy and Gourmet popcorns direct from our company.

Awarded Best of Zola
“We had our wedding reception at a brewery and wanted some easy to eat sweet and salty snacks. These popcorn flavors were delicious, they sent us flavors to try before we decided. We chose 4 flavors and they shipped them right to our house. The popcorn buckets had our cute custom labels which they designed for us and looked PERFECT! We had tons of compliments on the popcorn. We ordered plenty and people were grabbing them to take home at the end of the night. A perfect snack after a few beers. Theu were very fast with the samples and the order too!”
Lyndsey C., 2 years ago
GemHidden gem
Sugar, Spice and Nice Things 
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $192
  • Serves Smithtown, NY for additional fees
  • Offer

Sugar, Spice and Nice Things is a small bakeshop located in Hewlett, NY, on the South Shore of Nassau County, proudly serving customers on Long Island, NYC and beyond. We believe wholeheartedly in quality over quantity, so though we be but small, we are mighty! Our intention is to bake as fresh as possible with our quality ingredients for you to enjoy as soon as possible. At Sugar, Spice and Nice Things, we are constantly inspired by nature and appreciate life's great pleasures in the nice simple things. Best of Long Island 2026, Long Island Choice Awards 2025-2026

“SSNT creates the most beautiful cupcakes and cupcake bouquets I’ve ever seen! They make the whole process so easy, including customizations and off-menu requests. I’d highly recommend their products to everyone.”
LK, 2 years ago
TrendlineTrending
BakerBitesCo 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $200
  • Serves Smithtown, NY for additional fees

Ready to impress your guests with our unique tasty treat? BakerBitesCo offers single serve fudge bites with customized labels to fit your perfect day. Wedding favors, bridesmaids gifts, wedding party gifts, etc. these can be used in any way to fit your needs. WHY YOU'LL LOVE US -We offer delicious unique seasonal flavors -We ship anywhere in the US -We can send a sampler box so you can taste all our flavors and pick your favorites. -Budget friendly at only $2/piece -Prepackaged, making our dessert ideal during COVID -We give a meal to a hungry child with every order We can't wait to make your day even more spectacular!

“Best fudge I’ve ever had and the flavor varieties are amazing! I love that I can customize them for any occasion!”
Linda, 6 years ago
Quick responder
Dirty Pop NYC 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $750
  • Serves Smithtown, NY for additional fees

We are Dirty Pop NYC- a custom, full service dirty soda bar! We work with clients to fully customize their sodas from syrups to creamers and candy garnishes! With people drinking less, our team of retired bartenders are excited o whip up fun, creative craft beverages that will help everyone sober up a bit towards the end of the night and keep the party going!

“The Dirty Pop NYC team is fantastic! From working to gather to customize our menu, seamless set up and delicious drinks, we couldn’t have asked for a better team to come in and help out guests sober up a bit at the end of the night!”
Kevin R., 2 months ago